Stop the mistakes - play the odds from a process



When you repeat a mistake, it is not a mistake: it is a decision.
- Paulo Coelho

So what is an investment mistake? If the odds are 60/40 in your favor and you lose, is that a mistake or are you just unlucky? In this case, a bad outcome is just bad luck. If you calculate the odds to be 60/40 against you and you have a gain is that a lack of skill or just being lucky. These are important issues to consider if you want to measure or show skill. 

A mistake is not being rational or being inconsistent with an articulated decision process. If there is a process and the decision-maker deviates from the process, it is a mistake regardless of your luck. If you don't have a well articulated process, you will not be able to say that you made a mistake. A more fluid process allows for ambiguity and thus makes it hard to admit a mistake even during bad performance periods.

Given there is a process, the real issue is whether the decision-making model is wrong. If you are rationally following the model, the focus is on whether the model of market behavior is incorrect. If you consistently follow a disciplined process but if the model's predictive power is flawed, there is a mistake. Unfortunately, most models of asset prices can only explain a small portion of the variation in prices. Hence, mistakes can be repeated and turn into bad decisions.

Being systematic is just a start. It is the predictive process for which discipline is applied that really matters. Even here a trader faces a severe problem because mistakes are generally more frequent than success. A higher success ratio does not mean high returns. Success could be less than 50% yet produce higher returns. You can make repeated mistakes and still profit through controlling risk. A flawed model can still be effective if the trader cuts his losses. 

Mistake happen but decisions matter.

Komentar

Posting Komentar

Postingan populer dari blog ini

Three big picture trading themes to watch

Gambar
The Great Divergence in monetary policy Perhaps the Great Divergence in monetary policy between the Fed and ECB is not a great as expected given the weaker than expected policy change by the ECB, yet 2016 will continue to be the story between the Fed raising rates and the ECB pushing interest rates further into negative territory. Right before the ECB announcements the interest rate differential between Germany and the US was at the widest level since the introduction of the Euro. Yields in the EU jumped up and the Euro had one of the biggest positive days since its inception on the announcement only to see ECB president Draghi suggest that there is "no limit" to what the ECB will do to help the economy. The high volume of activity coupled with the price moves tells us that that many are trading this differential closely. Some of the most liquid markets in the world may still face cascades when these crowded trades are surprised.  Assume that the Fed raises rates in December,
Baca selengkapnya

Global macro themes for March on one page

Gambar
One month makes a big difference. We have gone from a hugely negative equity environment, oil crash fears, a credit downturn, and Fed policy mistakes to strong equites, an oil rally, and less credit risk. The economic environment has not changed radically, but when risk appetite changes the asset markets around the world change.  Can this last? This will be the number one question for March. We think there are still major headwinds to stop a sustained rally, but data change and markets change. Nevertheless, there needs to be confirming economic information to sustain the current rally. 
Baca selengkapnya

Vanessa Angel Dikabarkan Hamil, Sang Ayah Enggan Berkomentar

Gambar
See detail Belum lama menikah dengan Febri Ardiansyah, artis Vanessa Angel dikabarkan sudah berbadan dua. Sang ayah, Doddy Sudrajat enggan berkomentar tentang hal tersebut. “Saya nggak mau komentar soal kehamilan. Itu kan masalah pribadi. Tanya saja sama Vanessa secara langsung,” kata Doddy saat ditemui baru-baru ini. Doddy mengaku tidak melihat ada tanda-tanda kehamilan pada Vanessa. Dia juga tidak melihat perubahan pada sang putri. “Pas hari Sabtu (saat Vanessa Angel menikah dengan Bibi, Red) nggak terlihat perut Vanessa besar seperti orang hamil,” akunya. Doddy mengatakan, ia bersedia menikahkan Bibi dengan Vanessa Angel setelah menantunya itu datang secara baik-baik ke rumah. Doddy juga melihat keseriusan Bibi kepada Vanessa. Ketika disinggung soal resepsi pernikahan, Doddy enggan memberikan bocoran. Padahal sebelumnya sempat beredar kabar bahwa Vanessa Angel dan Febri Ardiansyah akan menggelar resepsi pernikahan di Bali akhir bulan ini. “Resepsinya ada, tapi nggak tahu waktu dan t
Baca selengkapnya